Book Review: The Anxious Generation by Jonathan Haidt

As both a high school teacher and a mother of a preteen, I find myself at the intersection of two worlds: the classroom, where I witness the effects of technology on students’ mental health, and my home, where I strive to protect my children from the same influences. Jonathan Haidt’s The Anxious Generation offers a compelling analysis of how the digital age has reshaped childhood and adolescence, often to the detriment of young people’s mental health.

As an early millennial–1982–I didn’t grow up with internet access at my fingertips. I don’t know what it is like to be a kid, pre-teen, teen or even young adult with the ability to access the internet and social media 24/7 via a cell phone. I’m not sure whether this is an advantage, disadvantage, or both when it comes to handling kids on phones in the classroom and in my own home.

Full disclosure: some of the links are affiliate links. If you choose to purchase a book and use the link, I will get a small commission that goes towards the maintenance of this site (at no extra cost to you). If you enjoy the content on this website, please do use the link if you choose to make a purchase.
Thanks for your support!

I was initially drawn to The Anxious Generation because the title resonated with my daily observations of students grappling with anxiety and stress. I anticipated a comprehensive exploration of various factors contributing to the mental health challenges faced by today’s youth. However, Haidt’s analysis narrowed the focus, identifying social media as the primary culprit behind the surge in adolescent anxiety.

He argues that the nature of platforms like Instagram, TikTok, and Snapchat foster constant social comparison, cyberbullying, and a distorted sense of reality, all of which exacerbate feelings of inadequacy and isolation, especially among pre teens.

Haidt also highlights the decline of unstructured, outdoor play—a vital component of healthy childhood development—as another significant factor. High stakes testing anyone? 🙁 He suggests that the combination of these elements fundamentally rewired how children interact with the world and each other. Sadly, I have to agree.

A Deep Dive into the Digital Dilemma

Haidt traces the origins of the current mental health crisis among teens to the early 2010s, coinciding with the widespread adoption of smartphones and social media platforms. He identifies a significant shift from a “play-based childhood,” characterized by outdoor activities and face-to-face interactions, to a “phone-based childhood,” where digital engagement often replaces real-world experiences. This transition, Haidt argues, has led to increased rates of anxiety, depression, and other mental health issues among adolescents.

The Four Foundational Reforms

In response to these challenges, Haidt proposes four key reforms aimed at mitigating the adverse effects of technology on youth:

1. No Smartphones Before High School: Haidt suggests delaying smartphone use until high school to prevent early exposure to the addictive nature of digital devices and the pressures of social media. I already broke this one with my own daugther.
2. No Social Media Before Age 16: He recommends postponing access to social media platforms until at least 16 years old to allow adolescents to develop a stronger sense of self before facing the challenges of online comparison and validation. I think this is reasonable and will try to enforce this with my children.
3. Phone-Free Schools: Haidt advocates for schools to implement policies that prohibit phone use during school hours, minimizing distractions and promoting more meaningful in-person interactions among students. Easier said than done, but more and more schools are doing. My school is jumping on the “no phone zone” wagon next year. Though I agree with the concept, I am not looking forward to enforcing it during lunch duty.
4. More Unsupervised Play and Childhood Independence: Encouraging unsupervised play and granting children more autonomy can help them develop resilience and coping skills essential for mental well-being. This is hard as a parent, and nearly impossible as a teacher. How much freedom we can safely give our kids in our particular life situations varies so greatly and given the sue happy culture of the United States, I doubt many, if any, schools will allow for unsupervised play–perhaps we could strive for more student driven, rather than adult driven, play in elementary schools.

Should you read it?

Are you a parent or a teacher, then YES.

The Anxious Generation serves as both a wake-up call and a guide for navigating the complexities of raising and educating children in the digital age. Haidt’s research underscores the urgency of addressing the mental health challenges faced by today’s youth and provides actionable steps for parents, educators, and policymakers to support the next generation in developing into healthy, resilient individuals. It is a timely resource for anyone committed to understanding and improving the mental health of our kids in an increasingly digital world.

Looking for more distractions from lesson planning? Check out these posts:

Recommended Reading: Brene Brown

Teacher fashion staples

Classroom supply splurges

5 Must-Haves for New Teachers

The Wannabe Teacher’s Guide 

5 Snacks teachers love

5 Recommended books for new teachers

If you found this post on reading The Anxious Generation helpful, make sure to pin, post, and tweet to share it with others who might also need some reading inspiration!

And don’t forget to scroll down to subscribe to get more great stuff like this.